Carter Strap-On Kit vs Shilo Bundle: Which Leather Set to Choose
By New York Toy Collective | Published: 2026-10-18
Category: Comparisons
Compare New York Toy Collective's Carter Strap-On Kit and Shilo + Leather Harness Bundle to find the leather strap-on set that fits your needs, budget, and style.
Quick Answer
Choose the Carter Strap-On Kit if you want the premium dual-density silicone with a thicker, posable feel; pick the Shilo + Leather Harness Bundle if you prefer a lighter, iconic design that's been a favorite for years and costs less.
Price vs. Experience
The Shilo bundle is priced at $213.89, while the Carter kit costs $224.39. Both are bundled to save you money compared to buying separately, but the $10.50 difference reflects a step up in the dildo's construction.
Carter's dual-density silicone offers a thicker, more substantial feel, which some users prefer for a more realistic experience. Shilo's posable design is lighter and has been a trusted favorite for over 14 years.
Design and Fit Considerations
Both kits include the same handcrafted Signature Leather Harness, so the fit and adjustability are identical. Your choice really comes down to which dildo suits your body and preferences.
Shilo is known for its iconic shape and has been worn by Ruby Rose in the viral 'Break Free' video, which might appeal to those who want a proven, recognizable option. Carter offers a more premium, tailored experience for those who want the best.
Trade-Offs at a Glance
- Budget: Shilo bundle costs $10.50 less than Carter. If saving money matters most, choose Shilo.
- Feel: Carter's dual-density silicone feels thicker and more realistic. If sensation is your priority, invest in Carter.
- Proven Popularity: Shilo has been a favorite for 14 years and is famous from the 'Break Free' video. If you want a time-tested icon, go with Shilo. Consider whether you value a premium feel or a proven classic more.
Product Facts
- Carter Strap-On Kit | Signature Leather Harness: Carter is a thick, posable dual-density silicone dildo paired with the Signature Leather Harness, priced at $224.39 (compare at $329.99). The dual-density silicone gives a more realistic, substantial feel, making it ideal for users who prioritize sensation and quality.
Carter Strap-On Kit | Signature Leather Harness - Shilo + Leather Harness Bundle | The Iconic Set: Shilo is the original posable silicone strap-on dildo, now paired with the Signature Leather Harness, priced at $213.89 (compare at $309.98). Shilo's lighter, proven design is a budget-friendly option that still delivers the flexibility and reliability you need.
Shilo + Leather Harness Bundle | The Iconic Set
Which Kit Fits You?
Best for
- Carter Strap-On Kit: users who want a premium, thicker dual-density silicone for a more realistic experience
- Shilo + Leather Harness Bundle: users who prefer a lighter, iconic design with a proven track record and a lower price
Not for
- Carter Strap-On Kit: budget-conscious shoppers who don't need the extra thickness
- Shilo + Leather Harness Bundle: those who prioritize the most realistic feel over cost savings
